192 S.E.2d 490 TOM C. CHAFIN, et al. v. HUGH WELLMAN, et al. No. 13265Supreme Court of Appeals of West Virginia.Submitted October 20, 1972. Decided November 14, 1972. 1. APPEAL AND ERROR — Where a court consists of multiple members and is equally divided, the last official ruling on the matter in question is affirmed. […]